Gifter’s Remorse: Property Ownership and Gifts

Share:

Once a gift is given, it cannot be taken back. The authority for that proposition is not just moral – it is exactly what the law says about gifts. The real question in any dispute involving an alleged gift therefore is not whether it can be taken back, the question is whether a gift was in fact made.

A gift is a gratuitous transfer of property to another, meaning for nothing in return. Most gifts are of modest value compared with property such as land or large sums of money, and they only rarely produce litigation because the amount at stake does not justify the mental, emotional and financial cost of litigation.

As the value of a gift increases, however, disputes are more likely to arise. Gifts of significant value are often made between close friends or family members, and when those relationships break down, the transferor may try to recover the property by recharacterizing the transfer as something other than a gift. For example, a transfer of money may be recast as a loan, or a transfer of land may be recast as having been done for some purpose other than a gift.

Proving A Gift

There are three elements required for a valid gift:

  1. an intention to make a gift;
  2. an acceptance of the gift by the recipient; and
  3. a sufficient act of delivery or transfer of the property to complete the transaction.

If these elements are satisfied, the transferor’s rights in the property come to an end and the recipient is free to deal with the property as they see fit.

In most cases, intention will be the hardest element to prove. Acceptance and delivery usually leave visible traces, such as depositing of money in a bank account or formal documents registered with the Land Title Office. Intention, on the other hand, is a state of mind that leaves little if any visible trace unless specifically recorded, which people often fail to do. Without contemporaneous records, the only evidence of intention will be the parties’ competing recollections of conversations that took place at the time of transfer.  

In a different post we recently discussed the resulting trust and how it allocates the legal burden of proof in disputes involving the transfer of property. If a transferor can show that the transferee gave no value for the property, the burden shifts to the recipient to demonstrate that a gift was intended. If the recipient cannot demonstrate that a gift was intended, they will be found to be holding the property in trust for the transferor and must return it.   Whether you are trying to recover property or defend a gift you received, its important to get litigation counsel early. A litigation lawyer can tell you at the outset whether the transfer is likely to be treated as a gift, and who will carry the burden of proof. Counsel can also identify and preserve the documents and witnesses that speak to intention before memories fade and records are lost. Because intention is so often the whole case, how that evidence is gathered and presented will frequently decide the outcome.

This article is intended for general information only and does not constitute legal advice.

Article by: Robert Goddard and Doug Conolly


Share:

Related Articles